In one of the more insidious bits of political data steering, the North Carolina General Assembly is proposing to limit the type of data used by planners to make predictions about sea level rise. The limitation states that only past data can be used to make projections, not models.
It would be easy to bang on the head of these folks for being so naked in their manipulations. They are avoiding making hard decisions in the hopes that the rising tide will just skip the entire state. As a professional that uses statistics and projections and models to compel good planning decisions, this is infuriating.
But it is truly difficult to be completely offended because things like this happens all the time. Jurisdictions pick and choose the most pleasant or self serving data to "prove" their points. Many central cities have been throwing out projections for growth for the last fifty years, although they've been hemorrhaging people. Adjustments are made to ridership projections to get new transit pushed through. Even the average tree size is a little lie told to make things better when laying out a parking lot. Those trees will never attain full growth, but we carry on like they will.
However, what should be disturbing to planners is that we most frequently do it ourselves.
One of the powerful tools that planners use to develop visions for communities is highlighting or suppressing feedback. When we survey an area, experience and education tell us what to report back to the community and elected officials. There's a little mysticism and a lot of training that help us pick out pathways and opportunities for development. Often, the things we don't like - big box retail or parking, to name a few - get suppressed in the name of planning orthodoxy.
Once it enters the black box of a planning mind, we do have biases that take over. We are biased towards sustainability. We are biased towards transit. We are biased towards best practices. Those are not minor data steering filters in their own right. They run in the thousands of dollars for staff time, millions for lost opportunities, and billions for infrastructure. It is not that these are incorrectly spent, but communities are steered towards these expenses without the benefit of complete information.
Indeed, it is easy to get angry at North Carolina when they are simply being overt about the self serving nature of data. It's really easy because data steering is a power we planners want to keep for ourselves.
Thursday, May 31, 2012
Wednesday, May 30, 2012
Royale With Cheese.
It has been almost twenty years since Pulp Fiction came out. The movie has been dissembled so many different ways, from the fractured timeline to the violence to the literary cursing. I was watching it tonight and was struck by something for the first time.
Pulp Fiction presents being in a car as a character all its own.
Sometimes films or shows present their settings as a unique character, one of the antagonists. I do not recall a movie where the act of being in a vehicle is treated as the truly unique setting it is. In a lot of films, the car is a hook to get from one place to another. Tolkien made folks walk for months, and a car is usually treated the same. In movies like American Graffiti, the car is a symbol of virile youth. Of course, the Road Trip is its own genre.
But for most of us, being in a car is being in a diving bell. You are moving through space, sealed off from the world around you. It creates a cabin fever. You act differently when you are stuck in a car with someone. You talk about the mundane. You stare uncomfortably forward, washed out from your encounter with an adrenaline needle. Hell, even the lead up to the famous dance scene takes place in a car (it just happens to be parked inside the restaurant).
We do act differently when we get behind the wheel. Differently enough to remember the next time we make decisions about driving and traffic while sitting behind a desk rather than a dashboard. I am not sure if it's the velocity or the freedom or the other folks whizzing by. It may even be that we drive so much we simply ignore the novelty of it all. We are not the same people when we become drivers.
Pulp Fiction presents being in a car as a character all its own.
Sometimes films or shows present their settings as a unique character, one of the antagonists. I do not recall a movie where the act of being in a vehicle is treated as the truly unique setting it is. In a lot of films, the car is a hook to get from one place to another. Tolkien made folks walk for months, and a car is usually treated the same. In movies like American Graffiti, the car is a symbol of virile youth. Of course, the Road Trip is its own genre.
But for most of us, being in a car is being in a diving bell. You are moving through space, sealed off from the world around you. It creates a cabin fever. You act differently when you are stuck in a car with someone. You talk about the mundane. You stare uncomfortably forward, washed out from your encounter with an adrenaline needle. Hell, even the lead up to the famous dance scene takes place in a car (it just happens to be parked inside the restaurant).
We do act differently when we get behind the wheel. Differently enough to remember the next time we make decisions about driving and traffic while sitting behind a desk rather than a dashboard. I am not sure if it's the velocity or the freedom or the other folks whizzing by. It may even be that we drive so much we simply ignore the novelty of it all. We are not the same people when we become drivers.
Tuesday, May 29, 2012
Four steps to a productive internship.
We received our shipment of interns today. They appeared hopeful. With any luck, this will continue throughout the summer and they will emerge as wholly formed and optimistic planners. Ones worthy of a entering a great profession. I will make it my personal mission that their spirits are not broken before they leave the Planning Department.
This will take some effort. I have been struggling with what to tell them to aid them during their time here. Some of this stems from recently reading Derek Sivers message to incoming students. Similar things have appeared elsewhere. It pains me that these things were never sent my way.
Until now. Here is my message to the interns.
1) Be narcissistic. We should talk about ourselves for a little bit. What do you like doing? What drew you to this field? What opportunities have you had? What did you like about them? What sucked? Yes, this is planning. Yes, we are whittling this down to a SWOT analysis. Suck it up. We are getting to something.
Are you simply meat? Are you simply going to be used as cheap labor? I don't think so. Stop thinking like a good little minion, and think as someone who is going to be going out into the worst job market in history burdened with tens of thousands of dollars in debt and competing against the perpetually unretired who have fifty years of experience. Let's figure out your strengths and weaknesses, then get working on them.
2) Let's set some goals for the time here. Again, this is about YOU, the paid intern looking at your selves and what you will be getting out of the position. This is about you preparing yourself for the next step in your career. Here is a theory. Here is another theory. If you don't like them, find another one.
But, again, I don't want to see any goals on here that involve "getting ten pages written." No. Make it about YOU. Start with one simple one, like, "Send follow up emails to ten new contacts." It is about doing one thing, which is meeting people. You then have to build on that thing by learning enough about the person to not simply be a poseur. Then you have to act on both parts by sending a followup email. The second one should be "Submit for a conference session."
3) Reporting. This is going to come in two parts: You will have weekly meetings with me first thing on Monday morning. 9am, no excuses. We will be going over a journal. That is the second part. Keep it short, with the list of things you did each day, filled out that day. This is going to be your running evidence of achieving things. It is also training you to cover your ass. If you did it, decided it, or dumped it off to someone else, it will appear in the journal.
4) No crap. If I see you gaming or goofing on Facebook, I'm going to embarrass you. Get your shit done. Get extra shit done for yourself. Get out of here. If you need more to do in order to fill the contingent eight hours you're required to be here, let me know. I have a list.
Now, I have not asked permission to do this, either yours or the supervisors. But I have been here long enough to know that this place eats your soul. It takes away the desire to be planners. I owe my chosen career a productive new generation of planners who are happy to be doing good work.
And I will be doing this with you. Anything I hold you to, I expect to be held to as well.
Until now. Here is my message to the interns.
1) Be narcissistic. We should talk about ourselves for a little bit. What do you like doing? What drew you to this field? What opportunities have you had? What did you like about them? What sucked? Yes, this is planning. Yes, we are whittling this down to a SWOT analysis. Suck it up. We are getting to something.
Are you simply meat? Are you simply going to be used as cheap labor? I don't think so. Stop thinking like a good little minion, and think as someone who is going to be going out into the worst job market in history burdened with tens of thousands of dollars in debt and competing against the perpetually unretired who have fifty years of experience. Let's figure out your strengths and weaknesses, then get working on them.
2) Let's set some goals for the time here. Again, this is about YOU, the paid intern looking at your selves and what you will be getting out of the position. This is about you preparing yourself for the next step in your career. Here is a theory. Here is another theory. If you don't like them, find another one.
But, again, I don't want to see any goals on here that involve "getting ten pages written." No. Make it about YOU. Start with one simple one, like, "Send follow up emails to ten new contacts." It is about doing one thing, which is meeting people. You then have to build on that thing by learning enough about the person to not simply be a poseur. Then you have to act on both parts by sending a followup email. The second one should be "Submit for a conference session."
3) Reporting. This is going to come in two parts: You will have weekly meetings with me first thing on Monday morning. 9am, no excuses. We will be going over a journal. That is the second part. Keep it short, with the list of things you did each day, filled out that day. This is going to be your running evidence of achieving things. It is also training you to cover your ass. If you did it, decided it, or dumped it off to someone else, it will appear in the journal.
4) No crap. If I see you gaming or goofing on Facebook, I'm going to embarrass you. Get your shit done. Get extra shit done for yourself. Get out of here. If you need more to do in order to fill the contingent eight hours you're required to be here, let me know. I have a list.
Now, I have not asked permission to do this, either yours or the supervisors. But I have been here long enough to know that this place eats your soul. It takes away the desire to be planners. I owe my chosen career a productive new generation of planners who are happy to be doing good work.
And I will be doing this with you. Anything I hold you to, I expect to be held to as well.
Friday, May 25, 2012
Bastard Bee
There is a thin separation between stand-in and go-to. We acquire things to stand-in for what we should be doing. But if they're around, then end up as a go-to.
Case in point. Honey Nut Cheerios.
We keep a box of Honey Nut Cheerios around as a stand-in for a more reasonable and healthful breakfast. Under normal conditions, I eat oatmeal and a banana and drink some OJ before heading out the door. The Brown Box sits on the shelf those days, peacefully waiting until need arises.
But then it starts to beckon. It speaks to me. "You don't want those things thinly masquerading as a true breakfast. YOU WANT THE REAL THING." I quake.
And so one morning there comes a time when real breakfast is "accidentally" forgotten, and I am left filling a punch bowl with sugar flavored oat rings and dropping my face into it without a spoon.
Case in point. Honey Nut Cheerios.
Oh dangerous succubus, oh shrew.
We keep a box of Honey Nut Cheerios around as a stand-in for a more reasonable and healthful breakfast. Under normal conditions, I eat oatmeal and a banana and drink some OJ before heading out the door. The Brown Box sits on the shelf those days, peacefully waiting until need arises.
But then it starts to beckon. It speaks to me. "You don't want those things thinly masquerading as a true breakfast. YOU WANT THE REAL THING." I quake.
And so one morning there comes a time when real breakfast is "accidentally" forgotten, and I am left filling a punch bowl with sugar flavored oat rings and dropping my face into it without a spoon.
Thursday, May 24, 2012
Sometimes I wonder if Planning is out of ideas. We have a limited number of set pieces that get new coats of paint every decade. The worst are the flagship projects - arenas, stadiums, convention centers, waterfront revitalization - that get some current buzzwords tacked on. Transit oriented. LEED Certified. You know the drill.
For example, the proposal for Baltimore's proposed new arena. For a city that has no professional basketball or hockey, it has the imminent stink of a white elephant. BUT IT HAS A GREEN ROOF.
What happens if we try something really startling. Let's not build a brand new arena. Let's not dump huge sums of cash on untested one-off transit modes. Let's not sink half a billion dollars into a money losing publicly owned hotel.
These big monsters hit a sweet spot between bulldozer politics and growth machine governance. We need NEW income to grow. That new income needs to come from NEW things. Politicians can attend ribbon cuttings at NEW things. Ergo, bring on the new arena.
But the concept is so deep in the mold that you can taste the penicillin. The tacked-on green roof just accentuates how poor the whole idea is. "How can we spruce up this off-the-shelf design? Let's add some grass!"
If you're going to blow my money on another boondoggle, at least make it an awesome boondoggle. Break through the boring. Maybe an arena integrated into an office block.
Or apartments in a second enclosure around the main stadium.
If you think of it, the most ancient of arenas - Madison Square Garden - does just this. It sits on top of Penn Station, the busiest train station in the country. There will be plenty of opportunities for transit development, as the new arena is going to sit near, if not at, the new Red Line.
Maybe finding the something to fit with the arena is thinking backwards. We do not even know if there will be occupants for the arena/expanded convention center. So we should make the arena the secondary function of the site. What would be useful here, that an arena can be integrated into?
Wednesday, May 23, 2012
Increasing Rates of Intelligence
Killer infographic from the CDC about the expansion in portion size from the 1950s to today. French fry sizes more than doubled. Burger sizes tripled. Soda sizes doubled THEN tripled.
This actually brought to mind another graphic, this one from Wired magazine a couple years back.
This shows the cost per calorie of items in the grocery store. Produce is the highest (2 cents per calorie) and beverages are the lowest (0.2 cents per calorie). Bread (0.2 cents per calorie) is also at the bottom, while meat (0.5 cents per calorie) is a bit higher.
Some of this has to do with urbanism. But we'll talk food deserts and nutrition later. Right now, I just want to admire when smart people translate hard information into beautiful bits of knowledge.
Tuesday, May 22, 2012
Behold the Metatron
It should be said that I really love the work I do. Being an urban planner is a calling, and one that I take seriously. When the constant drone of idiocy threatens the work and the community, it makes me very angry. So that gets prattled on about endlessly.
But cities, building them and understanding them, that is what makes for a Happy Planner. We get this unique opportunity to step backwards and just observe the glorious machine of human communities. We don't just watch it work, we try to add in the why and the how.
It's easy to scoff at the utility of planning when the field didn't exist for the first 100,000 years that people built places. A couple of decades of a profession doesn't offer respectability. And given the track record, planning hasn't helped itself be a respected field. When planners turned bulldozers on communities or tried to label places as slums, we lost a lot of ground. Tore up the roots of the seeds we should have been protecting. And we didn't pay attention that well when new seeds rooted. From those vanguard settlers, places that we tried to kill have come back, without our help.
That is the truly amazing part of cities. Even at their lowest functionality, cities work. People get where they need to go. Work is done. Food is acquired. Money changes hands. It may be slow or disjointed, but it all happens. When the non-functional gets abandoned, new houses go up, roads get filled, changes come fast.
All of which occurs on the surface. There is the deeper part of the city. Look hard at buildings and sidewalks and you will find that the city has ways of remembering things. Bricked in windows talk of changing utility and fashion. Growing front yards tell of evolving zoning codes. Bare ruts in the grass show thousands of feet cutting a new path. This is urban memory, the way the city records where it has been.
Couple that with the city taking action on its memory and current events. Look at the city as an organism. There is an urban intelligence, one that reacts to changes, retreats from threats, and actually decides how it is going to survive. And it does it based on its own history.
Memory and intelligence. But no voice. That is where planners should come in. We should speak for this emergent intelligence. We should be its mouthpiece.
We must do more than chatting up mixed use and transit oriented development and complete streets and the buzzword after that and after that. All of these things are superficial reshufflings of the houses and roads. They make nice places. But it is just for show.
What we need are new ways to peek into the mind of the city.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)